Thoughts on Healthcare Markets & Technology

Thoughts on Healthcare Markets & Technology

How Employers Can Use Public Rates, Evidence of Paid Claims and Verified Provider Networks to Contract for Outpatient Knee Replacements in Tampa Bay and Measure What They Actually Save

Nov 16, 2026
∙ Paid

🎧 Podcast episode for paid subscribers only. Also available on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.

Thoughts on Healthcare Markets & Technology
How Employers Can Use Public Rates, Evidence of Paid Claims and Verified Provider Networks to Contract for Outpatient Knee Replacements in Tampa Bay and Measure What They Actually Save
A self-funded employer coalition in Tampa Bay finds a low rate at a surgery center for outpatient knee replacements. Someone calls the surgeon’s office. The surgeon doesn’t operate there for total knees. That gap between a rate file and a real operating room is the whole problem

Listen now
5 minutes ago

To listen to paid episodes in Apple or Spotify, link your Substack subscription via the show settings on those platforms (instructions inside the Substack app under Subscriptions → Podcast).

Table of Contents

The rate file and the operating room

What the October rule actually changes

Building a Tampa Bay shortlist

Pricing the whole knee replacement

How many cases can actually move

Getting the contract through the claims system

What the buyer should pay for again

The rate file and the operating room

Thoughts on Healthcare Markets & Technology is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Abstract

Picture a self-funded employer coalition in Tampa Bay trying to buy outpatient knee replacements. Its administrator has a spreadsheet with a low negotiated rate at a surgery center in Pinellas County. The center looks close enough to where a lot of members live, and the spreadsheet makes a compelling case for calling procurement. Then someone calls the surgeon’s office. The surgeon sees patients in Pinellas but does joint replacements across the bay. The anesthesia group bills separately. The center offers joint surgery, but the scheduler who handles those cases has to check whether any of the surgeons taking new patients actually use that address for total knees. By the end of the call, the coalition has learned a great deal about the difference between shopping for surgery and shopping for a dishwasher.

A rate file can get a buyer into that conversation faster. The October rule makes it easier to find a rate in the relevant network and eventually gives the buyer a way to see whether the provider and service appeared together in historical claims. That’s a real improvement over a spreadsheet in which every rate looks equally credible. But the contracting decision depends on details that sit in different places. The published price belongs to a particular network and billing arrangement. The claims record belongs to a billing entity and may or may not identify the actual operating room. The availability of that operating room belongs to a scheduler, a surgeon and an anesthesia team whose calendars have little interest in the federal disclosure timetable.

For a startup, the first sale could be a paid contracting assessment for one procedure in one market. Hand the buyer a short list of facilities with claims evidence, an estimate of what comparable episodes have cost its members, a proposed bundle and a realistic range of cases that could move. There should be a named person at the administrator who can explain how the claims would pay and a named person at the facility who can say when the cases could happen. If the claims show the buyer already gets a good deal, that’s a perfectly sound outcome for a paid assessment. It also gives the vendor a reason to charge for the work up front. A business that gets paid only when it finds savings will eventually discover an astonishing number of savings.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Thoughts on Healthcare.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Healthcare Markets & Technology · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.