The Chargemaster Insurgency: What Steven Brill’s Healthcare Exposés Mean for Angel Investors in 2025

DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in this essay are solely my own and do not reflect the views, positions, or policies of my employer, Datavant, or any of its affiliates.

---

If you are interested in joining my generalist healthcare angel syndicate, reach out to trey@onhealthcare.tech or send me a DM. Accredited investors only.

---

ABSTRACT

This essay examines Steven Brill’s seminal healthcare journalism, specifically his 2013 TIME magazine investigation “Bitter Pill: Why Medical Bills Are Killing Us” and his 2015 book “America’s Bitter Pill: Money, Politics, Backroom Deals, and the Fight to Fix Our Broken Healthcare System.” For healthcare technology investors and entrepreneurs, Brill’s work provides critical insights into the pricing opacity, perverse incentives, and regulatory capture that define American healthcare economics. The analysis extracts actionable investment theses around price transparency technology, alternative payment models, and the structural arbitrage opportunities created by healthcare’s broken pricing mechanisms. Key takeaways include understanding how hospital chargemasters create exploitable information asymmetries, why the Affordable Care Act failed to address underlying cost drivers, and where technology companies can intervene in markets distorted by decades of regulatory and corporate rent-seeking.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction: The Journalist Who Made Healthcare Pricing a National Scandal

The Bitter Pill: Deconstructing Hospital Chargemasters and Price Opacity

America’s Bitter Pill: The ACA’s Compromises and Their Market Consequences

Investment Thesis One: Price Transparency as Infrastructure

Investment Thesis Two: Alternative Payment Models and Risk-Bearing Entities

Investment Thesis Three: Consumer-Directed Healthcare and Decision Support

The Brill Framework: What Entrepreneurs Get Wrong About Healthcare Reform

Conclusion: Building Businesses in Brill’s Shadow

Introduction: The Journalist Who Made Healthcare Pricing a National Scandal

Steven Brill isn’t a healthcare executive or a policy wonk or a venture capitalist, which is precisely why his work matters so much for anyone investing in health tech. He’s an investigative journalist who brought a fresh set of eyes to healthcare pricing and came away absolutely horrified at what he found. His 2013 TIME magazine piece “Bitter Pill: Why Medical Bills Are Killing Us” clocked in at over twenty thousand words and became one of the most widely read magazine articles in modern history. It did something remarkable: it made chargemasters a topic of dinner table conversation. Before Brill, most Americans had never heard the term. After Brill, everyone knew that hospitals had these mystical price lists that bore no relationship to actual costs or market dynamics and that uninsured patients were getting completely screwed by them.

Then in 2015 Brill published “America’s Bitter Pill,” which took a different angle. Instead of focusing purely on pricing opacity, he chronicled the backroom deals and compromises that shaped the Affordable Care Act. He had extraordinary access to the Obama administration and key congressional staffers, and what emerged was a portrait of healthcare reform as fundamentally constrained by incumbent interests. The book argues that the ACA expanded coverage but did almost nothing to address underlying cost drivers because doing so would have required taking on hospitals, pharmaceutical companies, and insurance carriers in ways that were politically untenable.